X-Git-Url: http://git.vanrenterghem.biz/git.ikiwiki.info.git/blobdiff_plain/fb26b9ca849b2cc8090e317c0cba790da76c425a..473071c4be84858d0a72c57622db3fe73e9c7ae8:/doc/bugs/img_vs_align.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/bugs/img_vs_align.mdwn b/doc/bugs/img_vs_align.mdwn
index dcb9129b9..5eb4489b0 100644
--- a/doc/bugs/img_vs_align.mdwn
+++ b/doc/bugs/img_vs_align.mdwn
@@ -5,7 +5,34 @@ embedded as `<p><img ...></p>`.  That's at least what I see on
 hand, CSS is supposed to be used instead, I guess.  (But how...  I forgot
 almost of my CSS foo again ;-) it seems.) --[[tschwinge]]
 
-> [[!img logo/ikiwiki.png align=right]]The [img tag doesn't create P tags](http://git.ikiwiki.info/?p=ikiwiki;a=blob;f=IkiWiki/Plugin/img.pm;h=32023fa97af8ba8e63192cacaff10a4677d20654;hb=HEAD), but if you have surrounded the img directive with newlines, they will result in paragraph tags.
+> [[!img logo/ikiwiki.png align=right]]The img tag doesn't create P tags, but if you have surrounded the img directive with newlines, they will result in paragraph tags.
 >
 > I've edited the URL you provided to demonstrate this -- hope you don't mind! I've also added an inline, right-aligned image to this page.[[!tag done]]
 > -- [[Jon]]
+
+> Contrary to all of the above, html does not care about P tags when
+> floating an image to the left or right via align. Proof:
+> <http://kitenet.net/~joey/pics/toomanypicturesofjoey/>, where the image
+> is in its own paragraph but still floats. Also, I re-modified a local
+> copy of the hurd page to enclose the image in a P, and it still floats.
+> 
+> Tested with Chromium and Firefox. --[[Joey]]
+
+>> Uh, sorry for not confirming what I supposed to be with looking into
+>> the relevant standard.  It just seemed too obvious to me that the
+>> closure of `<p>...</p>` would confine whatever embedded stuff may be
+>> doing.  (Meaning, I didn't expect that the *img*'s alignment would
+>> propagate to the *p*'s and would thus be visible from the outside.)
+>> 
+>> I confirm (Firefox, Ubuntu jaunty) that your picture page is being
+>> shown correctly -- thus I suppose that there's a buglet in our CSS
+>> scripts again...
+>> 
+>> --[[tschwinge]]
+
+>>> It seems, the 'align=right' parameter gets filtered in my installation
+>>> Are there other plugins, that could throw the parameter away?
+>>> --[[jwalzer]]
+
+>>>> Can't think of anything. htmlscrubber doesn't; tidy doesn't.
+>>>> --[[Joey]]