X-Git-Url: http://git.vanrenterghem.biz/git.ikiwiki.info.git/blobdiff_plain/d04a37be965d7525df88d916e18891bd445e1294..844169c9b06830df33ccde8abead015128baa496:/doc/wikitemplates/discussion.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/wikitemplates/discussion.mdwn b/doc/wikitemplates/discussion.mdwn
index 64b376679..f97444e5f 100644
--- a/doc/wikitemplates/discussion.mdwn
+++ b/doc/wikitemplates/discussion.mdwn
@@ -1,2 +1,46 @@
 ## Place for local templates
 Where does one put any locally modified templates for an individual ikiwiki? --Ivan Z.
+
+> You can put them whereever you like; the `templatedir` controls
+> where ikiwiki looks for them. --[[Joey]] 
+
+Thank you for your response! My question arose out of my intention to make
+custom templates for a wiki--specifically suited for the kind of  content
+it will have--so, that would mean I would want to distribute them through
+git together with other content of the wiki. So, for this case the
+separation of conceptually ONE thing (the content, the templates, and the
+config option which orders to use these templates) into THREE separate
+files/repos (the main content repo, the repo with templates, and the config
+file) is not convenient: instead of distributing a single repo, I have to
+tell people to take three things if they want to replicate this wiki. How
+would you solve this inconvenience? Perhaps, a default location of the
+templates *inside* the source repo would do?--Ivan Z.
+
+> I would avoid putting the templates in a subdirectory of the ikiwiki srcdir.
+> (I'd also avoid putting the ikiwiki setup file there.)
+> While it's safe to do either in some cases, there are configurations where
+> it's unsafe. For example, a malicious user could use attachment handling to
+> replace those files with their own, bad versions.
+> 
+> So, two ideas for where to put the templatedir and ikiwiki setup. 
+
+> * The easiest option is to put your wiki content in a subdirectory
+>   ("wiki", say) and point `srcdir` at that.
+>   then you can have another subdirectory for the wikitemplates,
+>   and put the setup file at the top.
+> * Another option if using git would be to have a separate branch,
+>   in the same git repository, that holds wikitemplates and the setup file.
+>   Then you check out the repository once to make the `srcdir` available,
+>   and have a second checkout, of the other branch, to make the other stuff
+>   available.
+> 
+> Note that with either of these methods, you have to watch out if
+> giving other direct commit access to the repository. They could
+> still edit the setup file and templates, so only trusted users should
+> be given access. (It is, however, perfectly safe to let people edit
+> the wiki via the web, and is even safe to configure
+> [[tips/untrusted_git_push]] to such a repository.) --[[Joey]]
+
+Thanks, that's a nice and simple idea: to have a subdirectory! I'll try it. --Ivan Z.
+
+A [[!taglink wish|wishlist]]: the ikiwiki program could be improved so that it follows the same logic as git in looking for its config: it could ascend directories until it finds an `.ikiwiki/` directory with `.ikiwiki/setup` and then uses that configuration. Now I'm tired to always type `ikiwiki --setup path/to/the/setup --refresh` when working in my working clone of the sources; I'd like to simply type `ikiwiki` instead, and let it find the setup file. The default location to look for templates could also be made to be a sibling of the setup file: `.ikiwiki/templates/`. --Ivan Z.