X-Git-Url: http://git.vanrenterghem.biz/git.ikiwiki.info.git/blobdiff_plain/a4ce0468f6f562ad4ec749f156528aa5b3f2fe39..19b9328520487f8682567cc871289fb4ebee9f00:/doc/ikiwiki/pagespec/discussion.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/ikiwiki/pagespec/discussion.mdwn b/doc/ikiwiki/pagespec/discussion.mdwn
index 4eed3722c..2857a98ba 100644
--- a/doc/ikiwiki/pagespec/discussion.mdwn
+++ b/doc/ikiwiki/pagespec/discussion.mdwn
@@ -92,3 +92,79 @@ does not seem suitable for this, as
 > \[[!map pages="./*"]]
 
 also lists the current page and all its siblings.
+
+---
+
+I am a little lost. I want to match the start page `/index.mdwn`. So I use
+
+    \[[!inline pages="/index"]]
+
+which does not work though. I also tried it in this Wiki. Just take a look at the end of the [[SandBox|sandbox]]. --[[PaulePanter]]
+
+> Unlike wikilinks, pagespecs match relative to the top of the wiki by
+> default. So lose the "/" and it will work. --[[Joey]]
+
+
+----
+
+I'd like to create a collapsable tree with a map, eg
+
+* top level item
+
+* * second level item1
+
+* * * content 1
+
+* * * content 2
+
+* * * content 3
+
+* * second level item2
+
+* * second level item3
+
+
+but I can't work out how to specify "all items at this level, and all directories at ../ and all the other directories to the root
+
+any ideas?
+
+> I don't think pagespecs currently support that. How would such a made-up
+> pagespec look? I can imagine it supporting something like `glob(../*) and not
+> glob(../*/*)` to match all "directories" of the parent page, and so on up
+> to the root. --[[Joey]] 
+
+>> I don't know, perhaps some way of nesting pagespecs 
+>>> glob(../* unless $_ eq 'second level item'{ glob 'second level item'/*}) 
+
+>> but that could get messy, perhaps a new cmd 'pagetree' or something 
+>> might be better? --Colin
+
+>>> You could probably do a lot worse than stealing terminology from 
+>>> [XPath Axes](http://www.w3.org/TR/xpath/#axes),
+>>> passing the "argument" through `bestlink` if there is one, and
+>>> treating an empty argument as "this page", something like:
+>>>
+>>> * `ancestor(/plugins/contrib/album)` matches `plugins` or
+>>>   `plugins/contrib`
+>>>   but not `plugins/map` or `plugins/contrib/album`
+>>>   (does it match `index`? answers on a postcard)
+>>> * `descendant(/plugins)` is basically `plugins/*`
+>>> * `child(/plugins)` is basically `plugins/* and !plugins/*/*`
+>>> * `self(/plugins)` is just `plugins` but without interpreting
+>>>   globs
+>>> * `ancestor-or-self(/plugins)`, `descendant-or-self(/plugins)`
+>>>   are syntactic sugar for e.g. `ancestor(/plugins) or self(/plugins)`
+>>> * `self()` always matches the current page (not destpage)
+>>> * `ancestor-or-self()` always matches the current pages and all
+>>>   pages that would go in its [[plugins/parentlinks]]
+>>>
+>>> XPath has `following-sibling` and `preceding-sibling` axes for
+>>> siblings, but pagespecs are unordered, so we'd probably want
+>>> to invent `sibling()` - so `sibling(/plugins/map)` matches
+>>> `plugins/inline` but not `plugins/map` or `plugins/contrib/album`.
+>>>
+>>> Then, the requested functionality would be `sibling() or ancestor()`,
+>>> or possibly `sibling() or ancestor() or self()`?
+>>> --[[smcv]]
+
+>>>> I like that idea! --[[KathrynAndersen]]