X-Git-Url: http://git.vanrenterghem.biz/git.ikiwiki.info.git/blobdiff_plain/835801a6ff13b23cf96b2d080805c095f7110315..7bbe9cf94d75b52fe979d87e4e3951514dbd1b76:/doc/todo/comments.mdwn diff --git a/doc/todo/comments.mdwn b/doc/todo/comments.mdwn index f5b580da2..7a113bee3 100644 --- a/doc/todo/comments.mdwn +++ b/doc/todo/comments.mdwn @@ -1,24 +1,170 @@ -Known issues with the [[plugins/comments]] plugin: +# Known issues with the [[plugins/comments]] plugin + +## Unimplemented + +* Instead of just a link to add a comment, it could have a form to enter + the title, similar to the form for adding a new blog post. + + > I'm not sure this is so useful? On Livejournal titles are allowed on + > comments, but very rarely used (and indeed usually not very useful); + > it's hard enough to get some people to title their blog posts :-) + > --[[smcv]] + +## Won't fix + +* Because IkiWiki generates static HTML, we can't have a form inlined in + page.tmpl where the user fills in an entire comment and can submit it in + a single button-press, without being vulnerable to cross-site request forgery. + So I'll put this in as wontfix. --[[smcv]] + + > Surely there's a way around that? + > A web 2.0 way comes to mind: The user clicks on a link + > to open the comment post form. While the nasty web 2.0 javascript :) + > is manipulating the page to add the form to it, it looks at the cookie + > and uses that to insert a sid field. + > + > Or, it could have a mandatory preview page and do the CSRF check then. + > --[[Joey]] + +* It would be useful to have a pagespec that always matches all comments on + pages matching a glob. Something like `comment(blog/*)`. + Perhaps postcomment could also be folded into this? Then the pagespec + would match both existing comments, as well as new comments that are + being posted. + + > Please see [[plugins/comments/discussion]]. If I've convinced you that + > internal pages are the way forward, then sure, we can do that, because + > people who can comment still won't be able to edit others' comments + > (one of my goals is that commenters can't put words into each other's + > mouths :-) ) + > + > On the other hand, if you still want me to switch this plugin to "real" + > pages, or if internal pages might become editable in future, then + > configuring lockedit/anonok so a user X can add comments to blog pages + > would also let X edit/delete comments on blog pages (including those + > written by others) in arbitrary ways, which doesn't seem good. --[[smcv]] + + > I had a look at implementing comment() and fell afoul of + > some optimisations that assume only internal() will be used to match + > internal pages. So probably this isn't worth doing. --[[Joey]] + +## Done * There is some common code cargo-culted from other plugins (notably inline and editpage) which should probably be shared -* Previews always say "unknown IP address" -* Add `COMMENTOPENID`: the authenticated/verified user name, if and only if it was an OpenID + + > Actually, there's less of this now than there used to be - a lot of simple + > things that were shared have become unshareable as they became more + > complex. --[[smcv]] + + > There's still goto. You have a branch for that. --[[Joey]] + + >> Now merged --[[smcv]] + * The default template should have a (?) icon next to unauthenticated users (with the IP address as title) and an OpenID icon next to OpenIDs + + > Done in my comments git branch, at least as a mockup (using the (?), + > {x} and {*} smileys for anonymous, OpenID and login respectively). + > --[[smcv]] + + >> I've improved this to use independent icons from the wikiicons + >> directory (untested!) --[[smcv]] + + >>> The new code produces links like /wikiisons/openid.png, which + >>> fail if ikiwiki is not at the root of the web server. --[[Joey]] + + >>>> Sorry, I should have spotted that (the assumption failed on my demo + >>>> site, but the push to that site was when I was on the way out, so I + >>>> didn't have time to investigate). As a note for other ikiwiki hackers, + >>>> I should have used + >>>> ``. --[[smcv]] + + >>> I got to wondering if the icons are needed. On my comments branch + >>> (not master), I've dropped the icons and info can be seen by hovering + >>> over the author's name. Idea being that you probably don't care how + >>> they authenticated unless something is weird, and in that case you + >>> can hover to check. Does that make sense, should I merge it? + >>> --[[Joey]] + + >>>> Yeah, go ahead. I preferred my layout with the author before the + >>>> comment - perhaps that's Livejournal's influence :-) - but I can always + >>>> edit the templates for my own site. As long as the default is something + >>>> reasonable and both layouts are possible, I don't really mind. + >>>> Minimizing the number of "resource" files in the basewiki also seems + >>>> a good goal. --[[smcv]] + +* Previews always say "unknown IP address" + + > Fixed in my comments branch by commits bc66a00b and 95b3bbbf --[[smcv]] + +* The Comments link in the "toolbar" is to `index.html#comments`, not the + desired `./#comments` + + > Fixed in my comments branch by commit 0844bd0b; commits 5b1cf21a + > and c42f174e fix another `beautify_urlpath` bug and add a regression test + > --[[smcv]] + + +* Now that inline has some comments-specific functionality anyway, it would + be good to output `` in Atom and the equivalent in RSS. + + > Fixed in my comments branch by d0d598e4, 3feebe31, 9e5f504e --[[smcv]] + + +* Add `COMMENTOPENID`: the authenticated/verified user name, if and only if it was an OpenID + + > Done in my comments git branch --[[smcv]] + + > Not seeing it there, which branch? --[[Joey]] + + >> Bah, git push --all is not the default... 'comments' branch now (I've also rebased it). + >> Sorry, I'm on mobile Internet at the moment... --[[smcv]] + + >>> merged by [[Joey]] in commit 0f03af38 --[[smcv]] + * Should the comments be visually set off more from the page above? Rather than just a horizontal rule, I'm thinking put the comments in a box like is used for inlined pages. -* Instead of just a link to add a comment, it could have a form to enter - the title, similar to the form for adding a new blog post. -* If a spammer posts a comment, it is either impossible or hard to clean - up via the web. Would be nice to have some kind of link on the comment - that allows trusted users to remove it (using the remove plugin of - course). + + > I did put them in a box in the CSS... I agree the default template + > could do with visual improvement though. --[[smcv]] + + >> I'll consider this solved by [[Joey]]'s changes. --[[smcv]] + * One can use inline to set up a feed of all comments posted to any page. - Using template=comments_display they are displayed right. Only problem + Using template=comment they are displayed right. Only problem is there is no indication in that template of what page each comment in the feed is a comment on. So, if a comment is inlined into a different page, I think it should show a link back to the page commented on. (BTW, the rss feed in this situation seems ok; there the link element points back to the parent page. + + > done --[[Joey]] + +* One of Joey's commit messages says "Not ideal, it would be nicer to jump to + the actual comment posted, but no anchor is available". In fact there is + an anchor - the `\[[_comment]]` preprocessing wraps the comment in a `
` + with id="comment_123" or something. I'll fix this, unless Joey gets there + first. --[[smcv]] + + > done --[[Joey]] + +* If a spammer posts a comment, it is either impossible or hard to clean + up via the web. Would be nice to have some kind of link on the comment + that allows trusted users to remove it (using the remove plugin of + course). + + > Won't the remove plugin refuse to remove internal pages? This would be + > a good feature to have, though. --[[smcv]] + + > Here, FWIW, is the first ikiwiki comment spam I've seen: + > + > So that took about 10 days... + > --[[Joey]] + + >> Implemented in my 'comments' branch, please review. It turns out + >> [[plugins/remove]] is happy to remove internal pages, so it was quite + >> easy to do. --[[smcv]] + + >>> done --[[Joey]]