X-Git-Url: http://git.vanrenterghem.biz/git.ikiwiki.info.git/blobdiff_plain/3b2772967fdb125bb8160f968729681b7af13269..3e2a78840a22c376e40dccd358e94533313596e8:/doc/plugins/contrib/getfield/discussion.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/plugins/contrib/getfield/discussion.mdwn b/doc/plugins/contrib/getfield/discussion.mdwn
index 78462197a..5f7fffead 100644
--- a/doc/plugins/contrib/getfield/discussion.mdwn
+++ b/doc/plugins/contrib/getfield/discussion.mdwn
@@ -7,6 +7,26 @@ Like you mentioned in [[ftemplate]] IIRC, it'll only work on the same page. If i
 > What do you think would be a good syntax for querying other pages?
 > It needs to resolve to a single page, though I guess using "bestlink" to find the closest page would mean that one didn't have to spell out the whole page.
 
+>> I don't know the internals very well, I think that's how other plugins do it. *goes to check* Usually it's a `foreach` loop, and use a `pagestate{foo}` to check the page's status/state. There's also some stuff like 'pagespec_match_list($params{page}` ... they do slightly different thing depending on need. --[[SR|users/simonraven]]
+
+>>> No, I meant what markup I should use; the actual implementation probably wouldn't be too difficult.
+
+>>> The current markup is {{$*fieldname*}}; what you're wanting, perhaps it should be represented like {{$*pagename*:*fieldname*}}, or {{$*pagename*::*fieldname*}} or something else...
+>>> -- [[KathrynAndersen]]
+
+>>>> Oh. Hmm. I like your idea actually, or alternately, in keeping more with other plugins, doing it like {{pagename/fieldname}}. The meaning of the separator is less clear with /, but avoids potential issues with filename clashes that have a colon in them. It also keeps a certain logic - at least to me. Either way, I think both are good choices. [[SR|users/simonraven]]
+
+>>>>> What about using {{pagename#fieldname}}? The meaning of the hash in URLs sort of fits with what is needed here (reference to a 'named' thing within the page) and it won't conflict with actual hash usages (unless we expect different named parts of pages to define different values for the same field ...)
+>>>>> -- [[Oblomov]]
+>>>>>> That's a good one too. --[[simonraven]]
+>>>>>>> Done!  I used {{$*pagename*#*fieldname*}} for the format. -- [[users/KathrynAndersen]]
+
+
 > I'm also working on a "report" plugin, which will basically apply a template like [[ftemplate]] does, but to a list of pages given from a pagespec, rather than the current page.
 
 > -- [[users/KathrynAndersen]]
+
+>> Ooh, sounds nice :) . --[[SR|users/simonraven]]
+
+>>> I've now released the [[plugins/contrib/report]] plugin.  I've been using it on my site; the holdup on releasing was because I hadn't yet written the docs for it. I hope you find it useful.
+>>> -- [[users/KathrynAndersen]]