X-Git-Url: http://git.vanrenterghem.biz/git.ikiwiki.info.git/blobdiff_plain/2f5c0a54809ed66fe8d0c43a6486288c2b61cd4c..cf1290eb464f1256aa5c12d973fff774e4f83e5e:/doc/todo/blogging.mdwn
diff --git a/doc/todo/blogging.mdwn b/doc/todo/blogging.mdwn
index cf6ba563e..a31674809 100644
--- a/doc/todo/blogging.mdwn
+++ b/doc/todo/blogging.mdwn
@@ -1,6 +1,3 @@
-- The [[TODO]] page would work better if the first N were shown in full,
- and then all open items were shown in summary. Maybe add this mode.
-- Add Discussion and Edit links at the bottom of each inlined post.
- It would be possible to support rss enclosures for eg, podcasts, pretty easily.
Here is the last of those items. Using the meta plugin you can give the appropriate
@@ -8,27 +5,27 @@ info, and the enclosure will be added to the entry. It will also add a
at the top, but I don't know if this is necessary. It also includes a fix for
when make is used without PREFIX.
-http://jameswestby.net/scratch/podcast.diff
+
-- JamesWestby
- Hmm. Not quite how I'd envisioned podcasts would work, my idea was
- more that the sound files would be kept inside the wiki, and the
- inline plugin could be told to eg, inline *.mp3, and would add
- those to the rss feed as enclosures. Maybe you'd also inline some
- regular blog pages to describe the files or the like.
+> Hmm. Not quite how I'd envisioned podcasts would work, my idea was
+> more that the sound files would be kept inside the wiki, and the
+> inline plugin could be told to eg, inline *.mp3, and would add
+> those to the rss feed as enclosures. Maybe you'd also inline some
+> regular blog pages to describe the files or the like.
- Do you think that would work or that it's worth pursuing that
- approach? I haven't looked at podcasts enough to know if that
- method would be technically feasable; for one thing it would limit
- the blog items for podcasts to just having an enclosure but no
- description.
+> Do you think that would work or that it's worth pursuing that
+> approach? I haven't looked at podcasts enough to know if that
+> method would be technically feasable; for one thing it would limit
+> the blog items for podcasts to just having an enclosure but no
+> description.
- Even if that doesn't work and pages are needed to desribe the items
- like you did, it still seems better to keep the podcast items in
- the wiki..
+> Even if that doesn't work and pages are needed to desribe the items
+> like you did, it still seems better to keep the podcast items in
+> the wiki..
- --[[Joey]]
+> --[[Joey]]
That's fair enough. I'm a little unsure of how it all works, so I just did the
simplest thing I could.
@@ -46,15 +43,95 @@ want to add a dependency on a IDv3 tag library. You could add another file
It's obviously up to you which way you want to go.
-http://jameswestby.net/scratch/podcast2.diff
+
-- JamesWestby
- Hmm, this could be taken a step further, and assume that if
- IkiWiki::pagetype doesn't return a defined page type for the page
- in the blog, then no matter the extension it should be fed into the
- rss feed in an enclosure. This would allow for not only podcasting,
- but vidcasting and a form of photo blogging. Or even an rss feed
- containing the source of ikiwiki. ;-)
-
- --[[Joey]]
+> Hmm, this could be taken a step further, and assume that if
+> IkiWiki::pagetype doesn't return a defined page type for the page
+> in the blog, then no matter the extension it should be fed into the
+> rss feed in an enclosure. This would allow for not only podcasting,
+> but vidcasting and a form of photo blogging. Or even an rss feed
+> containing the source of ikiwiki. ;-)
+>
+> --[[Joey]]
+
+Yes I agree that this would be great, but rss2 spec says that enclosure
+must have mime-type. How about I use the File::MimeInfo trick from the
+first patch to do this? I don't know why I didn't do this before.
+This will probably clean the code up a little as well.
+
+What do you think of the change that when using raw, if the filetype is not
+known it adds an entry anyway? I did this so that the entries appear if
+this mode is used. It might be that this is not necessary, as can we assume
+that people wont use raw if they want to pod/vid/whatevercast?
+
+-- JamesWestby
+
+> Using File::Mimeinfo makes sense to me.
+
+> I think it probably makes sense to make the (html) blog page
+> add an entry with a link to the file that's in the enclosure in the
+> rss feed. Whether or not raw is being used.
+
+> Note: I'm still unsure about whether podcasts should support
+> descriptions for the enclosures or not. Here's an early podcast
+> that did use descriptions:
+>
+> Here's a contemporary podcast, which also uses descriptions:
+>
+
+> The podcast client I use certianly doesn't care about the
+> descriptions. But it's podracer, probably not the thing most
+> podcast users use. :-)
+
+> --[[Joey]]
+
+I tested with amarok, and that also ignored the description.
+I am thinking of those where you have a mixed feed, and people
+using clients that ignore enclsures get pretty much a blank post,
+with just the filename, and the html page, which also just displays
+the filename.
+
+I don't think this is a big issue though, so I guess it's just which
+you think is the cleaner interface.
+
+I have also added the first of your ideas as well (though you seem to have
+removed it). It adds a parameter to inline `archive_after` which limits
+showing full entries to that number.
+
+
+
+-- JamesWestby
+
+> I removed it because I don't really see the need for it anymore.
+> The added complexity doesn't seem worth it, unless someone needs the
+> features. --[[Joey]]
+
+And here is the updated podcast patch supporting any file type.
+
+
+
+-- JamesWestby
+
+And here is a patch for the remaining item. It adds links to the bottom of
+inlined entries for edit and discuss (if they are enabled). It doesn't add
+links for edit if the filetype is not known.
+
+The stylesheet should probably be done slightly better than I have. I just
+added a bit of spacing as the links were too close to the date. I have no
+skill in this area though. Perhaps you would like to use the list system
+that you have for the links at the top.
+
+
+
+-- JamesWestby
+
+> Thanks! I did tweak the css a bit. Not totally happy with it, but pretty
+> good I think. (I'll try to get to the other patches soon.) --[[Joey]]
+
+
+---
+
+I'm very happy to report that this is [[todo/done]]. Podcasting patch
+applied (finally!) --[[Joey]]