X-Git-Url: http://git.vanrenterghem.biz/git.ikiwiki.info.git/blobdiff_plain/1e67780e626ea96482a5077b355dbced43a1f418..19700c70e54cd6d94cf02bf160d65f951dcb7d66:/doc/todo/else_parameter_for_map_plugin.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/todo/else_parameter_for_map_plugin.mdwn b/doc/todo/else_parameter_for_map_plugin.mdwn
index 8487f3564..981e50d43 100644
--- a/doc/todo/else_parameter_for_map_plugin.mdwn
+++ b/doc/todo/else_parameter_for_map_plugin.mdwn
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-[[!tag patch]]
+[[!tag patch done]]
 
 [[plugins/map]] (and I) could benefit from a bonus parameter:
 
@@ -14,14 +14,43 @@ documentation yet, I'm waiting for feedback first, but I'll do it for sure. -- [
 >> Hmmm, what do you mean? Adding a syntax such as the one below?
 >> Or something else?
 
-        \[[if test="map(" then="..." else="..."]]
+        \[[!if test="map(" then="..." else="..."]]
 
 >> What would you write in the `then` clause?
 >> I'm not opposed at all to rewrite my two-liner, but I don't understand.
 >> --[[intrigeri]]
 
-	\[[if  test="foo/*" then="""
-	\[[map pages="foo/*"]]
-	"""]]
+	\[[!if  test="foo/*" then="""
+	[[!map pages="foo/*"]]
+	""" else="no pages"]]
 
 --[[Joey]]
+
+>>> I'm not convinced: the syntax you're proposing implies to duplicate
+>>> the pagespec (once in the test clause, and once in the map query), which I find
+>>> not only inelegant, which I can live with, but also tiring and unpractical:
+>>> my `else` suggestion
+>>> finds its roots in map queries with rather long pagespecs. On the other
+>>> hand, if I'm the only one using map in such a way, I can live with this
+>>> heavy duplicated syntax without bloating the map plugin with features
+>>> no-one but me needs. On the other other hand, the patch is a 3-liner.
+>>> I'm not fixed yet, I'll think about it. --[[intrigeri]]
+
+>>>> Write a [[plugins/template]] which accepts a pagespec and an
+>>>> "else" clause, and then you won't have to duplicate the
+>>>> pagespec. --[[JoshTriplett]]
+
+>>>> Yeah, the patch is obviously very simple. My problem with it really is
+>>>> that there would seem to be several other places in ikiwiki where
+>>>> someone might want to be able to handle an "else" case where a
+>>>> pagespec expands to nothing. And adding else cases for all of them
+>>>> could be a bit much. --[[Joey]]
+
+>>>>> Agreed, and tagging as done. For the record, here is the [[plugins/template]] I use:
+
+        \[[!if test="<TMPL_VAR raw_pages>"
+        then="""<TMPL_VAR intro>
+        [[!map pages="<TMPL_VAR raw_pages>"]]"""
+        else="<TMPL_VAR else>"]]
+
+>>>>> --[[intrigeri]]