As to the question of whether the committer was the 'script' or the wiki editor... I'm not sure. Marking it as the script somehow (`ikiwiki-cgi <ikiwiki@sitename>`)? seems to make sense and would make it easier to manage.
-[[harningt]]
\ No newline at end of file
+[[harningt]]
+
+I've been thinking a bit about the GIT attribution in ikiwiki...
+
+If no email set, I think "$USERNAME" is reasonable... no point in the
+'<>' causing clutter.
+>> **adjustement wrt comments**: leave the '<>' in due to requirements in git
+
+If no username set... then something like '@[IPADDR]' makes sense...
+(not in email brackets).
+
+> Why not put it in email brackets? --[[Joey]]
+
+In the case of OpenID login.. I think that's a special case... I don't
+think attempting to munge something meaningful out of the OpenID makes
+sense... but I think some massaging might need to be done.
+
+Ex: I've noticed in the current mode where logging in w/
+harningt.eharning.us/ shows up in the logs w/o HTTP and if I login w/
+http://harningt.eharning.us/ is shows up w/ the http... causing some
+inconsistency. I think it oughtta make sure that it has the properly
+discovered, canonicalized form (ex: if there's a redirect to another
+site (harningt.eharning.us -> www.eharning.us) then technically the
+target site is the 'real' openid (at least according to how most OpenID
+RPs take it).
+
+...
+
+For OpenID edits, I think there should be a way to tell it what
+username to show in the preferences dialog (so you can have a 'normal'
+$USER <$EMAIL> setup.) This could by default be filled in w/ sreg
+nickname value (as well as email for that matter)...
+
+To convey the openid used to make the edit, I think it would be
+important that some sort of footer line along the lines of the
+Signed-off: $USER <$EMAIL> conventions I've seen.
+
+Perhaps an OpenID: $OPENID_URL would make sense. This could help w/
+making sure that no one irrefutably spoofs a post by someone (since w/
+the setup where email and effective username are configurable, there's
+no determination of uniqueness)
+>> **adj re git req**: "$OPENID_URL <>"
+
+[[harningt]]
+
+[[madduck]]: git requires `Name <Email@address>` format, as far as I know.
+
+> Yes, it does:
+>
+> joey@kodama:~/tmp/foo/bar>git commit --author "foo"
+> fatal: malformed --author parameter
+>
+> It seems to be happy with anything of the form "foo <foo>" -- doesn't seem to
+> do any kind of strict checking. Even "http://joey.kitenet.net <>" will be
+> accepted. --[[Joey]]
+>>
+>>Sounds good to me,
+>>
+>> --[[harningt]]
+
+> I think the thing to do is, as Josh suggested originally, use
+> GIT_AUTHOR_NAME and GIT_AUTHOR_EMAIL. Note that setting these
+> individually is best, so git can independently validate/sanitize both
+> (which it does do somewhat). Always put the username/openid/IP in
+> GIT_AUTHOR_NAME; if the user has configured an email address,
+> GIT_AUTHOR_EMAIL can also be set.
+>
+> There is one thing yet to be solved, and that is how to tell the
+> difference between a web commit by 'Joey Hess <joey\@kitenet.net>',
+> and a git commit by the same. I think we do want to differentiate these,
+> and the best way to do it seems to be to add a line to the end of the
+> commit message. Something like: "\n\nWeb-commit: true"
+>
+> For backwards compatability, the code that parses the current stuff needs
+> to be left in. But it will need to take care to only parse that if the
+> commit isn't flagged as a web commit! Else web committers could forge
+> commits from others. --[[Joey]]
+>
+> BTW, I decided not to use the user's email address in the commit, because
+> then the email becomes part of project history, and you don't really
+> expect that to happen when you give your email address on signup to a web
+> site.
+>
+> The problem with leaving the email empty is that it confuses some things
+> that try to parse it, including:
+> * cia (wants a username in there):
+> * git pull --rebase (?)
+> * github pushes to twitter ;-)
+>
+> So while I tried that way at first, I'm now leaning toward encoding the
+> username in the email address. Like "user <user\@web>", or
+> "joey <http://joey.kitenet.net/\@web>".