response to response

[git.ikiwiki.info.git] / doc / todo / mailnotification.mdwn

diff --git a/doc/todo/mailnotification.mdwn b/doc/todo/mailnotification.mdwn
index 5aae98894f8fcabc7307979459a01f3e0d3455ba..37fe9a55a3516602323eff2194c78ffaaf7f0eab 100644 (file)
--- a/doc/todo/mailnotification.mdwn
+++ b/doc/todo/mailnotification.mdwn
@@ -13,6 +13,24 @@ Should support mail notification of new and changed pages.
      Joey points out that this is actually a security hole, because Perl
      regexes let you embed (arbitrary?) Perl expressions inside them.  Yuck!
 
      Joey points out that this is actually a security hole, because Perl
      regexes let you embed (arbitrary?) Perl expressions inside them.  Yuck!
 

+(This is not actually true unless you "use re 'eval';", without which
+(?{ code }) is disabled for expressions which interpolate variables.
+See perldoc re, second paragraph of DESCRIPTION. It's a little iffy
+to allow arbitrary regexen, since it's fairly easy to craft a regular
+expression that takes unbounded time to run, but this can be avoided
+with the use of alarm to add a time limit. Something like
+
+    eval { # catches invalid regexen
+      no re 'eval'; # to be sure
+      local $SIG{ALRM} = sub { die };
+      alarm(1);
+      ... stuff involving m/$some_random_variable/ ...
+      alarm(0);
+    };
+    if ($@) { ... handle the error ... }
+
+should be safe. --[[WillThompson]])
+

      It would also be good to be able to subscribe to all pages except discussion pages or the SandBox: `* !*/discussion !sandobx`, maybe --[[Joey]]
 
   3. Of course if you do that, you want to have form processing on the user
      It would also be good to be able to subscribe to all pages except discussion pages or the SandBox: `* !*/discussion !sandobx`, maybe --[[Joey]]
 
   3. Of course if you do that, you want to have form processing on the user


@@ -34,3 +52,8 @@ Should support mail notification of new and changed pages.
      into a folder.
 
   --[[BrandenRobinson]]
      into a folder.
 
   --[[BrandenRobinson]]

+
+  I'm deferring these nicities until there's some demonstrated demand
+  --[[Joey]].
+
+[[todo/done]]